Are you looking for a booster or a convertible car seat for your older kids? If you do, you're at the right place!
The article targets the two most prominent booster and convertible car seats on the market!
This is the final battle between the two supreme models: Chicco MyFit vs Britax Grow With You car seats!
Both are supreme in safety features, comfort, ease of use, and installation. But, who's better? Stay tuned.
Table of Contents
- Chicco MyFit vs Britax Grow With You: The Ultimate 2022 Contrast
- Chicco MyFit: Pros & Cons
- Britax Grow With You: Pros & Cons
- Britax Grow With You vs Chicco MyFit: The Final Verdict
Chicco MyFit vs Britax Grow With You: The Ultimate 2022 Contrast
You know that Chicco and Britax are the absolute leaders in the car seat market. No other car seat brand is as prestigious as these two. They never let us down.
So, let's compare the two booster seats this time and see which is better for your older child.
1. Design and configurations
Both car seats are booster - combination car seat models. Both offer the following two-car seat modes:
- extended forward-facing car seat for kids 2-65 pounds
- booster mode for children 40-120 pounds.
None of the car seats uses the backless booster seat mode. Therefore, it would help if you referred to other backless booster models to find the best solution.
However, the Chicco MyFit belt-positioning booster seat has a smaller height and weight limit.
Namely, the Britax Grow With You booster seat offers 120 pounds of the maximum weight limit and 63 inches of the maximum height limit.
On the other hand, the Chicco MyFit, both in harness mode and booster mode, provides 57 inches of maximum height limit and 100 pounds of the weight limit.
In addition, the Chicco MyFit booster seat is a narrower booster car seat, with the following measurements: 18.75 x 17 x 27 inches, weighing 25 pounds.
However, the Britax booster car seat measures 21 x 19 x 25 inches and weighs 23 pounds.
So, both booster car seats are incredibly lightweight for the purpose, and you can install them in the back of your vehicle effortlessly.
However, if you want a lighter version supporting more weight limit to combine well, then you should undoubtedly choose the Britax Grow With You booster car seat.
The Chicco MyFit is somewhat limited but fits more car seats, so you can choose as you like - the result is a tie.
2. Advanced specifications
The Chicco and Britax seats are only the primary modes of the booster/convertible car seat models.
Both models are advanced and improved, so both have the car seat series.
Thus, the Chicco MyFit includes the following:
- Chicco MyFit Zip Harness + Booster Car Seat, and the ultimate
- Chicco MyFit Zip Air 2-in-1 Harness + Booster Car Seat is the final version in the Chicco MyFit series.
On the other hand, the Britax booster seat includes the following:
- Britax Grow with You ClickTight Harness-2-Booster Car Seat, and the most advanced
- Britax Grow with You ClickTight Plus Harness-2-Booster Car Seat is the final version of the Britax Grow With You series.
So, you can compare the Britax Grow With You ClickTight vs Chicco MyFit Zip or the Chicco MyFit Zip Air vs. Britax Grow With You ClickTight as well for more advanced contrast.
But in the end, you will find the same results as the two primary car seats.
The Chicco MyFit models are narrower, with a smaller weight range, while the Britax car seats are broader but with greater height and weight range for tall kids.
Thus, for the Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus vs Chicco MyFit Zip Air, and specifications, I once again vote for the Britax models.
3. Safety features
Both car seat brands offer supreme safety standards for your children. Both meet and exceed all federal safety standards, rigorous crash tests, and similar benefits.
The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety - IIHS rated the Chicco models as the best seat for the growing children.
However, all Britax car seats include the SafeCell crumple zone technology.
The system includes the energy-absorbing foam for redirecting and collecting the external forces, pressure, and impacts in an accident, keeping your little ones safe and sound.
In addition, the Grow With You and Grow With You ClickTight offer two layers of side impact protection, the steel-reinforced frame, and the V-shaped tether, to reduce the movement and keep the booster seats stable and fixed.
On the other hand, the Grow With You ClickTight Plus uses three layers of side-impact protection, with all other safety features necessary for a perfect car seat.
Your little one will be safe and stable in rear-front or side collisions.
And the steel reinforcement only increases the child's safety, offering more support and keeping the child's neck, spine, torso, and head optimal and intact.
So, it's a great seat for extended use.
On the other hand, we have the Chicco MyFit combination harness mode and booster mode and the company of the other two advanced models.
The car seat provides two layers of side-impact protection with the steel frame. Thus, it ensures the entire torso and neck protection for your child.
Moreover, the car seat uses the Superior DuoGuard with a deep rigid shell. And, due to the steel frame, the forward-facing/booster seat won't move around in rear, frontal and side collisions.
Now, both car seats offer the five-point harness mode - an extended version for increased weight range and robust kiddos.
It will provide more safety and stability in the extended forward-facing car seats when your child isn't ready for the seat belt-positioning booster.
However, the more advanced Chicco forward-facing car seats also offer the exact child safety seat mechanism with the steel frame and additional layer of the SIP.
But, due to two and three layers of the SIP, I prefer the Britax forward-facing seat rather than the Chicco.
4. Car seat installation process
The Britax forward-facing car seat offers two installation modes: the LATCH system and the vehicle seat belt system.
Now, the Grow With You doesn't have the ClickTight installation, but you can still use either mode to install it correctly.
You must thread the seat belt through the belt path and tighten it for the proper installation.
Or, match the LATCH connectors with the car seat attachments to tighten the seat and set it adequately.
But, the two advanced versions offer the ClickTight system.
It can be installed with the LATCH connectors or the seat belt, but the manufacturer recommends the belt as the primary installation.
You can install the forward-facing seat models in harness mode when you open the seat, thread the belts through the belt path, and close it to lock them into place.
You can also use the LATCH connectors and the car seat attachments, but the experts recommend the belt system as the first to avoid LATCH complications.
On the other hand, the Chicco car seat models also use the seat belt and LATCH system for the effortless installation.
Moreover, the car seat offers superior LATCH connectors and the advanced LockSure seat belt system for the quickest setup. So, it easily installs in both harness mode and booster mode.
Ensure you use the LATCH strap correctly to find suitable connectors and tighten them for maximum stability.
The technology also includes the ReclineSure leveling and the RideRight bubble levels for the proper fit in the vehicle seat.
However, the MyFit Zipper Air includes the SuperCinch LATCH system for straightforward installation.
So, according to your seat belt or LATCH preferences, you can choose the best car seat. The result is a tie in this category.
5. Comfort benefits
Regarding the Chicco seat, it offers the ultimate comfort for your child! Namely, the seat uses the four recline positions and nine positions of the no-rethread harness.
So, you will have to adjust the five-point harness straps and the proper harness height for your growing child.
In addition, the seat is advanced due to the deepest, contoured ErgoBoost dual-density foam padding. So, it offers comfier and cozier rides in both modes.
The seat also has the breathable mesh, but the Zip Air models have the breathable 3D Air Mesh for extra airflow and circulation for the ultimate coziness.
Contrary to Chicco, the Britax sea uses only two recline positions, but like Chicco, it also offers nine parts of the five-point harness and headrest for your growing child.
The two positions and the adjustments will help you fit the seat into the vehicle and create more comfort for your little ones.
But, the Grow With You, ClickTight & ClickTight Plus also include the chest pads to create more coziness for the kids in the seats.
The breathable materials and content only increase the comfort benefits, and the no-rethread harness mode will help you stabilize the growing kiddo adequately.
However, when using both brands in the booster modes, ensure the shoulder belt and the lap belt are in the proper place to fix your children and create more comfort.
Otherwise, they won't be safe.
And both harness systems offer padded shoulder straps to enhance comfort and prevent pressure for the harnessed children.
Again, both seats are extraordinary in comfort. But since Chicco utilizes more reclining options and premium-quality materials, I would choose it over Britax.
6. Extra features
Chicco seats come with two dishwasher-safe cup holders, which is crucial for long-distance trips. And, when they're too messy, you can quickly wash the two cup holders.
They are removable and foldable to ensure more seat comfort and room.
Britax includes four snack and cup holders. The snack holders will help you focus better on the road while your kids can enjoy their meals.
So, depending on your needs, you can choose either model. Britax also includes easy-to-wash and remove cup holders, so it's up to you what you will choose.
7. Cleaning and maintenance
Both brands utilize the machine washable cover. It will save your time and energy, and you can provide maximum freshness for subsequent use.
However, some experts still recommend the hand-washing of the Britax rather than machine washing in the first two models.
The ClickTight Plus is specific for the machine washable cover.
So, Chicco models might be slightly advanced, but you can choose as you like. You cannot go wrong.
8. FAA approval
To ensure your car seat is FAA-approved, you should find the label stating they are optimal for motor vehicle and aircraft use. It should be somewhere at the bottom of the seat.
Luckily, both our competitors are FAA-approved seats. However, you can use them only in the harness mode!
You cannot install and use them as boosters, as they need seat belts. But, the harness is fine, in the extended forward-facing mode, with an appropriate high weight limit.
So, you can choose either of the competitors; they will be OK for the plane.
However, I suggest you still check the specific airline's rules, as they might vary. So, to avoid complications at the airport and later on the plane, you should contact them first.
And what about the prices? Are these car seats expensive or not? Let's see.
Wow, this rarely happens. Both seats have the precisely same price tags, around $200. So, you can pick a suitable model according to your preferences.
Similar boosters might cost even more, so you practically get two-in-one seats for a reduced price.
The other two models are around $100 more expensive, but they are advanced, so, logically, they will have higher price tags.
On the other hand, the advanced Britax seats have higher prices due to the advanced performance and better benefits compared to the primary model. So, they are worth the price.
And, as all prices are similar, you can choose as you like.
Chicco MyFit: Pros & Cons
- Two-in-one car seat
- Quick setup with both seat belt and LATCH
- Two cup holders
- Comfort benefits
- Long lifespan
- Fitting more in a row
- More adjustment options
- Safety and protection
- Quick installation, but not as advanced as with other models
- Although lighter, more oversized car seat, it is still bulky for a rapid movement between more vehicles
Britax Grow With You: Pros & Cons
- Numerous safety standards and protection benefits
- Higher weight range
- Effortless installation
- Quick switching modes
- Durable, robust construction
- Longer lifespan
- Stable and fixed - no wriggling in the back seat
- Robust, so it's tricky to move it quickly between the vehicles
- Hand washable content
- Less reclining options than Chicco and similar models
How wide is Britax Grow with you?
It's more comprehensive than the Chicco opponent. Its proportions measure 21 x 19 x 25 inches, so it's 19 inches wide.
On the other hand, the Chico model is 17 inches wide, so it might better fit more car seats in the back of your vehicle.
Is Britax Grow With You ClickTight FAA approved?
Yes, Britax Grow With You ClickTight is FAA approved. You will find the label stating that it is FAA-approved at the bottom of the car seat.
However, you can use it only in the forward-facing harness mode on the plane; you cannot use it as a booster. No boosters are allowed on the plane.
Is Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus worth it?
Yes, Britax Grow With You ClickTight Plus definitely is worth!
The convertible/booster seat is an ideal model for older and growing kids, so it's a perfect option for all parents.
Due to its quick installation, premium machine-washable materials, and comfort benefits will last longer, and your kids will be cozier.
However, the top benefit is maximum safety features since it offers three SIP layers, with the existing SafeCell and other safety benefits. So, it provides maximum stability and safety!
How long is Chicco MyFit suitable for?
It offers an eight-year lifespan from the date of manufacture. You can find the serial number and the expiration date on the back of the car seat.
Its opponent Britax has a nine-year lifespan, so it lasts longer.
How vast is the Chicco MyFit?
It has the following proportions: 18.75 x 17 x 27 inches, so it's 17 inches wide. However, it's narrower than the Britax model, so it easily fits more seats at the back of your vehicle.
What is the difference between Grow With You ClickTight and Grow With You ClickTight Plus?
The first difference is in the specifications and weight. Namely, the Plus variant weighs more and offers a broader dimension compared to the former car seat.
The Plus is also advanced due to machine-washable materials, which the ClickTight lacks.
But, above all, the main difference is in the safety standards. The Plus version has three layers of SIP in the form of external cushions, so it offers advanced protection.
The regular ClickTight model utilizes two SIP layers - the foam-lined headrest and energy-absorbing shell, so there's no third layer.
Britax Grow With You vs Chicco MyFit: The Final Verdict
So, what will you choose as your ultimate winner? Will it be Chicco or Britax? I know it's a fierce battle, and it will be challenging to decide quickly.
In terms of safety and installation, I would choose Britax. Still, in terms of comfort and maintenance, Chicco is my favorite!
Hopefully, the article helps you decide easier. Tell me once you pick your final winner, OK?