Britax Vs. Chicco: How to Select Correctly (A Must-read 2021 List)

As parents or parents-to-be, your kids mean the world to you. Logically, you'll want to use the best car seats to protect them on the road and provide them with supreme comfort and safety features.

Therefore, you need to pick the best car seats! But what's the hack? It might be challenging for you to select the best ones.

That's why I'm guiding you in this comprehensive article and reviewing the pros & cons, and benefits of Britax and Chicco car seats. When I provide you with the essential info, you'll be able to choose wisely and obtain your best seats; therefore, let's begin!

Through various car seats, I'll compare these two brands so that you can evaluate them properly and select the best option for your little angels.

So, stay with me, and read below!

More...

Britax vs. Chicco: Safety Features and Standards

britax vs chicco travel system

It's undeniable that both brands - Britax & Chicco provide the ultimate protection and safety for your children. Both brands have side-impact protection, energy-absorbing foam, sturdy and reliable steel frames, and durable shells. Moreover, both brands provide car seats with cavernous sidewalls that keep your little ones' heads and neck in various frontal, side, rear, and other crashes.

However, if you look at the NHTSA table, where they rate car seats according to the safety features, Britax has a slightly better score than Chicco since the Britax seats don't have less than a 4-star rating in any category.

As far as I can remember, in 2015, Britax won the title and was rated #1 as the safest and easiest car seat brand in the car seat industry. The brand also won the maximum points in the flame retardant category. This way, they only confirmed that their materials are user-friendly and safe for kids' skin.

Additionally, the Britax Marathon ClickTight car seat also won the prize of being number #1 in the best convertible car seat category. So many advantages and benefits, don't you agree?

Contrary to Britax, the Chicco brand doesn't have as many prizes as Britax has. However, satisfied customers and parents still find it a high-quality brand that provides the safest and most comfortable car seats and other following equipment.

Despite all reviews, in my opinion, as a certified CPST, Britax is safer than Chicco.

Quick and Effortless Installation Process

britax vs chicco booster seat

When speaking about this process, I must tell you that Britax came up with the revolutionary and the brand new updated way to install their car seats into your motor vehicles. The new technology is known as the ClickTight installation system, and various Britax car seats use this technology, such as Marathon, Boulevard, Advocate, but many other seats.

When you install car seats with the LATCH system and connectors, there are many tricky steps to follow, and if you miss only one, you can expose your little ones to severe risks and possible injuries. But here, things change.

The ClickTight technology offers you the possibility to install your car seats only with regular seat belts, without the LATCH limits. And, unlike the LATCH, the ClickTight installation makes your setup process effortless, as modern technology does all the work for you.

On the other hand, Chicco has come up with a new car seat installation process, and they undoubtedly transformed the traditional setup process with the LATCH.

Most Chicco car seats have the LockSure seat belt system and SuperCinch tightener. This tightener is a force-multiplying one and ensures you place the car seat accurately and secure it tightly with the LATCH system and connectors. The LockSure system helps you thread your car seat through and comes with the integrated lock-offs for the straightforward and super-easy installation process.

While both brands invented the process that will save your time and energy, my vote would still go to Britax, as they do have the quickest installation process. It seems that Chicco pays more attention to security during installation (WHICH IS EXCELLENT); however, Britax is more practical and faster.

But I have to say that Chicco provides more stability during the installation with LATCH since other brands tend to make it easier.

The Extended Use

The most popular Britax car seats: ClickTight car seats have a ten years expiration date. Compared to them, Chicco car seats have eight years of the lifespan for their most popular NextFit models nowadays.

As you can see, both manufacturers produce car seats that you can buy once and let your kids use for quite an extended period. You don't have to worry whether something might go wrong during all these years since the seats are made to last and keep your children safe and protected. The more prolonged use becomes only a more significant bonus!

Ease of Use

According to various NHTSA ratings and reviews, Britax appears to have higher overall ease of use than Chicco car seats. These ratings include how easy it is for parents to comprehend and follow the instruction manuals and how easy they can get their children out of the car seats.

While comparing these two brands and examining the NHTSA results, I could notice that these ratings are confirmed and backed up by the consumers.

Highest Quality & Sovereign Comfort

britax vs chicco infant car seat

The Britax ClickTight car seats originate from the USA and meet all safety standards. Thus, these seats provide the engineered impact-stabilizing steel frame, including the best stability, security, and safety where the car seat meets your motor vehicle's seat.

Concerning the fabrics, these seats have machine-washable and dryer-safe contents that will save your time and energy when cleaning them. Moreover, the paddings are full of plush foam for a more comfortable and relaxing atmosphere when in the car seats.

From another point of view, Chicco shows that their NextFit series of car seats originate from China. Yet, they have the engineered steel-reinforced frames and the EPS energy-absorbing foam that adds more to the supreme side-impact protection. These seats have a removable infant insert, so they provide more space and comfort for your growing children.

Further, the seats also offer a breathable 3D air mesh that provides a cooling effect, reducing the heat and increasing airflow and air circulation. The padded ComfortFlex harness system provides more stability for your kids, and all the other elements make the seats the most convenient and comfortable to use.

My points here go 50-50 - to Britax because it's a domestic product, and to Chicco since they undoubtedly put all their efforts to keep children relaxed, cozy, and comfortable.

Significant Similarities Between Britax and Chicco Car Seats

  • ClickTight and NextFit car seat models both provide the benefits in terms of the more comfortable and quick setup process.
  • Both brands create the car seats with the steel-reinforced frame for more durability and sturdiness. Thus, the seats will last for an extended time and keep your kiddos safe.
  • Both convertible car seats have a minimum weight limit of 5 pounds, and a maximum weight limit of 65 pounds.

Significant Differences Between Britax and Chicco Car Seats

  • NextFit models primarily have the system designed to make the seat belt installation process effortless and straightforward.
  • ClickTight models are heavier than the NextFit car seats.
  • ClickTight models have a more extended use (10 years), whereas NextFit models have an 8-year expiration date.
  • ClickTight models have seven reclining angles followed by the level indicator, which ensures that you have chosen the right angle and that your seat is ready for installation. Unlike that, Chicco NextFit seats have the nine positions of the ReclineSure leveling system and the double RideRight indicators, ensuring that you installed the seats correctly.
  • Britax produces car seats in America, while Chicco in China.

Pros and Cons for Britax vs. Chicco

1. Britax

Sale
Britax Marathon ClickTight Convertible Car Seat | 1 Layer Impact Protection - Rear & Forward Facing...*
  • Easy installation: patented click tight makes car seat installation as simple as buckling a seat belt
  • No rethreading, ever: 14 position harness, 2 position buckle for a comfortable Fit as your child grows. Child seated shoulder height Rear-Facing: 7.6 - 18.65 inch
  • Relax and recline: 7 recline positions ensure comfort and the best vehicle installation angle
  • Surrounded in safety: a layer of side impact protection, steel frame and impact absorbing base
  • Fits: rear facing 5 to 40 pounds and forward facing 20 to 65 pounds; dimensions: 23 x 18.5 x 23.5 inches (LxWxH); Shoulder Width 16 inch
Pros
  • Make LATCH installation quicker and effortless
  • Made in the USA
  • Excellent side-impact and SafeCell protection
  • Cheaper than the Chicco car seats
  • They have the ClickTight installation system 
Cons
  • Tricky to uninstall these seats
  • Heavier and more robust than the Chicco car seats
  • ClickTight models don’t have a cup holder

2. Chicco

Chicco NextFit Zip Air Convertible Car Seat, Azzurro*
  • Assembled Product Dimensions: 21" D x 19" W x 26" H | Total Harness Slot Height: 17" | Product Interior Seat Depth: 13.5" | Assembled Product Weight: 25 lbs
  • Remarkably easy installation with a 9-position ReclineSure leveling system, SuperCinch LATCH Tightener and LockSure seat belt tightening system
  • Superior DuoGuard protection with a deep rigid shell and EPS energy-absorbing foam, plus a steel-reinforced frame
  • Accommodates growing children with a removable newborn positioner, no-rethread harness, 9-position headrest, and easy transition from rear-facing to forward-facing
  • Breathable 3D AirMesh backrest, soft zip-off seat pad, and ComfortFlex waist belt for comfort and convenience
Pros
  • They have a belt-locking system that makes the setup part easier and straightforward
  • Lightweight car seats
  • The Zip covers ensure the simplest and quickest removal and replacement
  • NextFit models have the premium LATCH attachments
  • Easy to install
Cons
  • Made in China
  • Too expensive
  • Tricky to get your kids out of these car seats

Final Verdict

britax advocate vs chicco nextfit zip

Generally speaking, both Britax and Chicco produce car seats that are comfortable, secure, and above all, safe.

Both brands are ideal options for parents or future parents if they search for easy-to-use car seats that deliver safety and comfort as a primary benefit. Moreover, both manufacturers create seats with the highest quality so that specific models stand out.

It may be a little tough to decide whether to choose Britax with the ClickTight system or Chicco with the SuperCinch installation system.

Having examined all parts thoroughly, my choice would still be Britax due to various recognitions, extensive awards, but safety recognitions, above all. It's my top choice also for premium comfort, installation device, and maximum safety, which make every single Britax car seat unique and special.

Hopefully, after reading this detailed article, you will have a better insight and form an opinion about which producer creates better car seats and your perfect choice!

Kathy Warner

Kathy is a busy mother of two and a CPS technician for more than eight years. Her mission is to awaken parents to the importance of child passenger safety and show them the right practice. You can read more about her here

Leave a Comment